Complete Brand Analysis • Independent vs. Corporate-Owned • 2025 Edition
Last Updated: January 2025
⚠️ SHOCKING FACT: Mars Inc. and Nestlé control over 70% of the North American pet food market. Mars owns 41+ pet food brands AND the largest veterinary hospital chains (Banfield, BluePearl, VCA) - creating massive conflicts of interest in what your vet recommends.
✅ TOP INDEPENDENT CHOICES - Truly Family-Owned, Non-GMO Brands:
Fromm Family Foods - 5th generation family-owned, Wisconsin-based, own manufacturing
Farmina - Italian family-owned, zero GMO in entire feed chain
Midwestern Pet Foods - 4th generation family-owned (Earthborn Holistic)
📊 Quick Reference Guide
Green = Safe: Independent/family-owned, no corporate ties
Yellow = Caution: PE/VC backed but no vet/pharma ties
Red = Avoid: Corporate owned or has vet/pharma ties
Brand
Non-GMO Status
Ownership
Vet/Pharma Ties
Recommendation
✅ TRULY INDEPENDENT BRANDS (HIGHLY RECOMMENDED)
Fromm Family Foods
✓ Non-GMO ingredients
5th generation family-owned (Wisconsin)
✓ None
BEST CHOICE
Farmina
✓ 100% GMO-free (Italian standards)
Family-owned (Italy)
✓ None
BEST CHOICE
Nature's Logic
✓ 100% GMO-free whole foods
Independent company
✓ None
BEST CHOICE
NutriSource
✓ Non-GMO
Family-owned (KLN Family Brands)
✓ None
EXCELLENT
Diamond Pet Foods
✓ Non-GMO options
Family-owned (Schell & Kampeter families)
✓ None
GOOD(Does contract mfg)
Gentle Giants
✓ Natural Non-GMO
Independent
✓ None
GOOD
Midwestern Pet Foods (Earthborn Holistic, Pro Pac)
✓ Non-GMO options
4th generation family-owned
✓ None
GOOD
⚠️ PRIVATE EQUITY/VC BACKED (USE WITH CAUTION)
The Honest Kitchen
✓ Non-GMO verified
$150M from Monarch Alternative Capital (PE)
✓ No ownership ties Works with vets only
ACCEPTABLE
Open Farm
✓ Non-GMO verified
$65M+ from General Atlantic & Encore Capital
✓ No direct ties
ACCEPTABLE
Ollie
✓ Non-GMO
Venture capital backed
✓ No direct ties
ACCEPTABLE
Tender & True
✓ Organic/Non-GMO
Unclear ownership
Unknown
UNCERTAIN
❌ CORPORATE OWNED - STRONGLY AVOID
Nutro
✓ Non-GMO claims
✗ Mars Inc.
✗ Mars owns vet hospitals
AVOID
Orijen/Acana
✓ Quality ingredients
✗ Mars Inc. (2022 acquisition)
✗ Mars owns vet chains
AVOID
Royal Canin
Limited non-GMO
✗ Mars Inc.
✗ Heavy vet prescription diets
AVOID
IAMS
Limited non-GMO
✗ Mars Inc.
✗ Mars owns vet chains
AVOID
Eukanuba
Limited non-GMO
✗ Mars Inc.
✗ Mars owns vet chains
AVOID
Organix (Castor & Pollux)
✓ USDA Organic
✗ Nestlé Purina
✗ Nestlé vet investments
AVOID
Merrick
Quality ingredients
✗ Nestlé Purina
✗ Nestlé vet ties
AVOID
Hill's Science Diet
Limited non-GMO
✗ Colgate-Palmolive
✗ Prescription diet empire
AVOID
Blue Buffalo
Some non-GMO options
✗ General Mills
Corporate owned
AVOID
Natural Balance
Some quality options
✗ J.M. Smucker
Corporate owned
AVOID
Rachael Ray Nutrish
Limited non-GMO
✗ J.M. Smucker
Corporate owned
AVOID
Major Corporate Ownership to Avoid
Mars Inc. (41% market share): Owns Nutro, Pedigree, Royal Canin, IAMS, Eukanuba, Cesar, and recently acquired Orijen/Acana. Also owns Banfield, BluePearl, VCA veterinary hospitals.
NutriSource - Family-owned, excellent track record
Acceptable Alternatives (if above unavailable): The Honest Kitchen, Open Farm (despite PE backing, they have no vet ties)
Disclaimer: This guide is based on publicly available information as of January 2025. Ownership structures can change rapidly through acquisitions. Always verify current ownership before purchasing. This guide is for informational purposes only and is not veterinary advice. Consult with an independent veterinary nutritionist for specific dietary needs.
📥 To Save as PDF: Click "Download/Print as PDF" button at top, then select "Save as PDF" in your print dialog. Share this guide to help other pet owners make informed choices!